Blue-hour covered terrace with ivory stucco, limestone paving, two woven lounge chairs and bronze-framed glass doors.
| November 12, 2026

Two Newer Lake Mary Ice Cream Shops, Two Very Different Ideas of "Homemade"

At the Lake Mary Village plaza, a few minutes off I-4, Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream has a roomy dining room and a row of tables along the front patio. A short drive away, at 1541 International Parkway, Sunny's Ice Cream works out of Suite 1021. Its sister restaurant, Tamara Lake Mary, is next door at #1011 and serves curries and biryani at a full bar, with hookah on the outdoor patio.

Both counters sell premium, handcrafted ice cream. Each got to that label by a different route. One is a Central Florida brand that started as a single truck. The other is a family restaurant group's dessert counter stocked with small-batch ice cream made in Sarasota. Those origins explain why the shops look and feel different, and they set when each one turns off its lights.

The pink truck that became a seventh scoop shop

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream started in 2013. According to the grand-opening announcement in the Sanford Herald, founder Kelly Seidl first sold her own recipes from a custom pink step van at local farmers markets. The "pink truck" became well known around town, and the business grew into a string of neighborhood scoop shops.

Lake Mary got its shop this year. Kelly's held a daylong grand opening on Saturday, January 24, 2026, at 3801 W. Lake Mary Blvd. #129. The schedule included a children's entertainer, games and crafts, a toppings happy hour, and a magician in the evening. Orlando Weekly reported in November 2025 that the shop would open before the end of that year. It opened about a month later than that forecast.

Kelly's own Lake Mary page calls it the company's "seventh scoop shop." The menu is scoops, sundaes and shakes, and there is an online ordering link for people who would rather pick up. By the time this shop opened, the brand had grown well past the farmers markets where it started. What came to Lake Mary is a format the company has built over more than a decade, with a spacious dining room and front-patio tables.

Sunny's ice cream comes from Sarasota and sits next to a curry house

Sunny's describes itself on its About page as "Lake Mary's newest destination for handcrafted, premium ice cream." The ice cream is Amish-style, made in small batches in Sarasota with traditional methods and high-butterfat cream, which the shop says gives it a smooth, creamy texture. Most flavors use natural ingredients and are naturally sweetened. A few, such as Cookie Monster and Cotton Candy, are brightly colored on purpose. The counter also carries dairy-free and sugar-free options.

So the "homemade" at Sunny's describes a production style. The ice cream is made in small batches by traditional methods in Sarasota, then served in Lake Mary. At Kelly's, the word points to a founder's recipes and a company that grew out of Central Florida farmers markets. Both are honest uses of the word, and they tell you where each product comes from.

The Sunny's menu leans toward pie and bakery flavors:

  • Raspberry Dream
  • Strawberries N' Cream
  • Brown Sugar Cinnamon
  • Banana Cream Pie
  • Blueberry Cheesecake
  • Triple Peanut Butter
  • Mudslide
  • Espresso Chip
  • Pistachio
  • Salted Caramel Praline
  • Cookie Monster

What really sets Sunny's apart is its neighbor. Mandy and Gagan Singh, whose family owns Tamara Lake Mary, opened Sunny's next door shortly after the restaurant, according to a Lake Mary Life profile. Tamara serves traditional Indian dishes, including curries, kabobs and biryani, along with Chinese and Thai food. Orlando Weekly noted that the restaurant took over the space that used to house The Nine Heathrow Thai Grill & Kitchen. In its November 2026 profile, Lake Mary Life reported that Tamara Lake Mary had more than 1,000 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating.

That puts dinner and dessert at one address on International Parkway, with a short walk between them. The Lake Mary Life profile also says Sunny's runs community partnerships, including fundraisers for schools and sports teams. Parents who coordinate spirit nights may want to remember that.

After 10 p.m., most of the counters are closed

Pairing an ice cream counter with a restaurant that has a full bar and a hookah patio shows up in the hours. Below are the posted hours for Lake Mary's two newer shops and two established ones, taken from each business's own listing. Hours change, so check before a late run.

Shop Address Sun–Thu close Fri–Sat close
Sunny's Ice Cream 1541 International Pkwy., Suite 1021 11 p.m. Midnight
Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream 3801 W. Lake Mary Blvd. #129 10 p.m. 11 p.m.
Jeremiah's Italian Ice 4355 W. Lake Mary Blvd. 10 p.m. Mon–Thu, 11 p.m. Sun 11 p.m.
Menchie's Frozen Yogurt 1120 Town Park Ave., Colonial TownPark 9 p.m. 10 p.m.

On a weeknight, Sunny's posted hours run an hour past Kelly's and two hours past Menchie's. On Fridays and Saturdays, it is the only shop on this list still serving at midnight. Sunny's opens at 11:30 a.m. every day. Kelly's opens at noon Monday through Friday and at 11 a.m. on weekends.

Sharing an address with a full-service restaurant lets Sunny's serve dessert to diners finishing a late meal next door. Kelly's 10 p.m. weeknight close and 11 p.m. weekend close fit an evening out with the family.

How the established counters fit around the new two

Kelly's and Sunny's arrived in a town that already had two very different frozen-dessert stops.

Jeremiah's Italian Ice, on W. Lake Mary Blvd., opens at noon every day and closes at 11 p.m. Friday through Sunday. Of the four on the list, it is the closest match to Kelly's weekend hours.

Menchie's Frozen Yogurt at Colonial TownPark has the shortest day, opening at 1 p.m. and closing at 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday. Its frozen yogurt lineup rotates and includes sorbet and vegan options. The company notes that flavors change by region, season and location. It works best for an afternoon or early evening stop, especially paired with a walk around TownPark. Our guide to things to do in Lake Mary has more ideas for filling out that kind of outing.

The new shops change the late-evening options the most. Since January 2026, there has been a Central Florida brand's scoop shop with a dining room on W. Lake Mary Blvd., plus a counter on International Parkway that serves Sarasota-made Amish-style ice cream until midnight on weekends, right next to a restaurant with a full bar. If dinner is the main plan, our Lake Mary restaurant guide and date night ideas list places to eat before dessert.

For families, the choice often comes down to the room. Kelly's has the dining room and front-patio seating. For anyone with dietary limits, Sunny's dairy-free and sugar-free options are the detail to know. For a late dessert after dinner on International Parkway, Sunny's is the counter still open.

If you would like more of the local know-how The Mel Bernstein Team has picked up over decades in Lake Mary, from the newest dessert stop to the streets you would choose for a walk afterward, we would be glad to share it. Let's Connect.

Recent Blog Posts

View All Blogs
Follow Us on Instagram
@